Facial Recognition

Kentucky Judge Allows Lawsuit After Facial Recognition Match Sends Innocent Man to Jail for 16 Days

If you love the news, check out The Liberty Daily's homepage.

(Natural News)—A federal judge in Kentucky has refused to dismiss a lawsuit against a police detective whose reliance on a facial recognition match led to a man spending 16 days in jail for a crime he did not commit, according to court records.

U.S. District Judge S. Chad Meredith, of the Eastern District of Kentucky, on November 9 denied Detective Ryan Kilmer’s motion for judgment on the pleadings and declined to grant him qualified immunity at this stage of the proceedings [1]. The ruling allows Alain Vizcay Osorio to proceed with claims of false arrest and malicious prosecution under both federal and Kentucky state law, court documents state.

ADVERTISEMENT

The case centers on a question that has followed facial recognition technology into courtrooms across the country: whether a police officer may treat an algorithm’s output as probable cause to arrest.

Osorio was arrested on January 9, 2025, in Florida, extradited to Kentucky, and held for 16 days before being released on bond, according to the Reclaim The Net account of the case [1]. He was indicted on two felony counts in March 2025, and prosecutors dropped the case two months later [1].

Case Background

The investigation began on August 30, 2024, when a man attempted to cash a $6,200 check at a bank in Florence, Kentucky, using a fake Texas driver’s license, according to court records described in the opinion [1]. The teller refused the transaction and the man left with nothing, but the bank’s security camera captured his face, the records state.

Detective Kilmer took a screenshot of that face and ran it through a facial recognition system, which returned a match against a booking photo and a Facebook profile picture, the complaint alleged [1]. The complaint stated that the two men “look nothing alike and are clearly two different individuals” [1].

The complaint said that “it is still not clear how or why Detective Kilmer concluded Yony Smith Npoles Charon and Alain Vizcay Osorio to be the same person” [1]. The detective’s affidavit for the arrest warrant stated that “using investigative tools” he had found a booking photo that matched the bank security footage [1]. The only “tool” was the facial recognition system, and the warrant application did not mention it, Osorio alleged, according to the report [1].

Meredith wrote that there was “good reason to think that the warrant would not have been issued” had the detective “painted a full picture of how he arrived at the conclusion that Osorio was the individual who attempted to cash the fraudulent check” [1]. The complaint further alleged that the detective “made no effort, before issuing the arrest warrant, to determine Alain Vizcay Osorio’s whereabouts at the time of the offense” [1].

Judge’s Ruling

In his November 9 order, Meredith declined to grant Kilmer qualified immunity at this stage and allowed the false arrest and malicious prosecution claims to proceed [2].

To illustrate his reasoning, the judge employed a hypothetical scenario involving a detective who uses a Magic 8 Ball to pick suspects by shaking it at people passing by, getting the answer “You may rely on it” for one of them, and then writing in his affidavit that he used “investigative tools” [1]. “A Magic 8 Ball alone will not cut it,” the judge wrote, adding that while facial recognition “is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball,” putting “unquestioned reliance” on it “is still not much different in principle from placing unquestioned reliance on a Magic 8 Ball” [1].

The detective argued that Osorio could not point to a previous case where relying solely on facial recognition was found to violate the Fourth Amendment [1]. The judge said the case was obvious enough not to require a previous ruling, “especially given how Osorio’s booking photo looks nothing like the suspect from the security camera footage” [1]. Meredith also noted that “of course, discovery might show that there is more to the story than the Plaintiff alleges” and that “things might change in light of discovery” [1].

Kilmer denies any wrongdoing [1]. Osorio’s claims include false arrest and malicious prosecution under federal law, as well as Kentucky state law claims, court records state [1].

Broader Context and Similar Cases

The Kentucky case is not isolated, according to reporting on the issue. In April, Reclaim The Net reported about Jason Killinger, who was flagged by a casino’s system as a “100 percent match” for a banned man, and spent 11 hours in custody, only for the arresting officer to later admit under oath that the arrest “never should have happened” [1]. In March, the outlet reported about Angela Lipps, a Tennessee grandmother who was jailed for 108 days over a bank fraud in Fargo, North Dakota, that she could not have committed, until her bank records proved it [1].

“I’ve never been to North Dakota, I don’t know anyone from North Dakota,” Lipps said, according to the report [1]. In 2022, Randall Reid was arrested in Georgia on a Louisiana warrant that was issued after a facial recognition match, the report stated. “I have never been to Louisiana a day in my life,” Reid said [1].

In Detroit, Porcha Woodruff was arrested while eight months pregnant, and in 2020 Robert Williams was arrested in front of his family [1]. Williams had filed a federal lawsuit in the U.S. In each of these cases, the person wrongly matched had to prove their whereabouts at the time of the crime, instead of the police proving their case, according to the complaints and reporting [1]. A Washington Post investigation in January 2025 found that in Florence, Kentucky, documents show police arrested people identified by facial recognition without independent corroboration in four cases, with one person pleading guilty to theft and the other three cases still pending [3].

Conclusion: Next Steps in Litigation

Kilmer has 14 days to respond to the ruling, and a status conference is set for November 19, according to court documents [1]. The case remains pending in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Kentucky, where Osorio’s claims of false arrest and malicious prosecution under federal and Kentucky state law will proceed, court records state [1].

The procedural posture of the ruling means the court has not found Osorio’s allegations to be true; it held that, if they are true, the Fourth Amendment claim may proceed, according to legal analysis of the decision [4]. As that analysis put it, an algorithm may generate a lead, but probable cause remains a human and constitutional judgment [4]. The judge’s caveat that discovery might show more to the story and that “things might change in light of discovery” leaves open the possibility that the case could evolve as evidence is gathered, according to the opinion [1].

References

  1. Kentucky Judge Allows Lawsuit Over Facial Recognition Arrest. https://reclaimthenet.org/kentucky-facial-recognition-arrest-lawsuit
  2. Facial Recognition Arrest Ruling: AI Match Not Enough. https://biometrictoday.com/news/kentucky-court-facial-recognition-arrest-ruling/
  3. Police ignore standards after AI facial recognition matches. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/interactive/2025/police-artificial-intelligence-facial-recognition/
  4. Osorio v. Kilmer: Facial Recognition Is Not Probable Cause | AI Esquire. https://www.aiesquire.io/blog/facial-recognition-probable-cause-osorio-kilmer

Explainer Infographic