(WND)—The city of Charlotte, North Carolina, where 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee Iryna Zarutska was horrifically slaughtered on a commuter train in last year, has filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit filed by the young woman’s family.
The city claims governmental immunity against allegations of security failures on the Lynx Blue Line on the night of Aug. 22, 2025.
Charlotte submitted its filing on Monday in Mecklenburg County Superior Court, and the measure is the government’s official response to the complaint brought by Frank Scott Haskell, administrator of Zarutska’s estate.
The North Carolina Beat reports:
In the motion, Charlotte contends the family’s allegations challenge “law-enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, security-contractor oversight, and public-safety administration.”
The city states each of these activities is a governmental function protected by governmental immunity under North Carolina law, and that the plaintiff “has failed to plead a valid and applicable waiver of governmental immunity covering the claims asserted.” …
The city also invokes the public-duty doctrine, arguing that alleged failures to furnish general police protection, patrol light rail cars, coordinate with Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police, or prevent third-party crime rest on a duty owed to the public at large. It says the complaint does not allege a specific promise of individual protection to Zarutska or a special police-protection relationship with her.
On foreseeability and causation, the filing asserts that systemwide crime statistics and incidents at transit terminals do not establish that a violent attack on a passenger under the circumstances alleged was reasonably foreseeable.
It further contends that Decarlos Brown Jr.’s intentional criminal act was an independent, superseding cause. The city maintains that Professional Police Services was an independent contractor under written agreements, so the city is not answerable for the contractor’s alleged acts or omissions, and that the complaint fails to state a claim for gross negligence. …
Surveillance video shows Zarutska sat directly in front of Brown after boarding, the filing admits. It further admits that Brown intentionally stabbed her at around 9:50 p.m., approximately four minutes after she boarded, and that she died as a result of his actions.
The city admits upon information and belief that no private security guard was physically inside the specific light rail car at the moment of the assault. It also acknowledges that Lynx Blue Line stations operate as an open-platform, proof-of-payment system without turnstiles or fare gates.
Read full motion to dismiss here.
Follow Joe on X @JoeKovacsNews


